"Give me your tired, your poor,
Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,
The wretched refuse of your teeming shore.
Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me,
I lift my lamp beside the golden door!"
~ "The New Colossus" by Emma Lazarus, 1883
There is a lot of misinformation circulating about the purpose of Occupy Wall Street. This is my attempt to dispel some of the most commonly issued rumors regarding the reasons behind these demonstrations and the sincerity of the people involved in them. These are all actual complaints I have seen either on Twitter or on the news.
I will not make it to NYC until next week after my mid-terms are over. (Mustn't let that crushing student debt go to waste on failed classes.) I cannot speak for everyone there. Crowds of this size draw as many different beliefs and ideals as they do people. Everyone who is there is there for their own personal reasons. No two stories are exactly the same. I write this not as an ultimate authority on the movement, but as a soon-to-be active participant who has been waiting many years for a time such as this.
I am proud of my generation and the older generations standing alongside us. I know that not everyone has a way with words, and that many people find themselves tongue-tied when confronted with a news camera. Many intelligent, compassionate people are being labelled as ignorant simply because they lack the words to express how they feel. This is my attempt to help them out with the only tool I have until I can add my body to the march. I sincerely hope this document spreads beyond my usual circle of readers and reaches the hands of those on the ground in New York, L.A., Philadelphia, Seattle, Austin, and more.
Without further ado...
1. OWS is too unorganized to become a true force of social change.
Really?
They conduct General Assemblies each day at appointed times, during which protesters come together to democratically plan their strategy. They spread news to the far edges of the crowd by participating in Human Mic Checks. They have their own Media Team which is streaming the Occupation live twenty-four hours a day. They published their own newspaper last week. (The Occupied Wall Street Journal, of course.) They have stations set up within Liberty Plaza to distribute food, water, and sanitary supplies to protesters. They have a library. They have an area where protesters can charge their electronic devices. Today, they had free hair cuts.
The truth is that OWS is not just an organized, peaceful demonstration. It is an organized, peaceful micro-society taking root in the heart of Manhattan.
Business people love to talk about tribes. They dream of creating an amazing product that a tribe can rally around. Now, it's happening in the streets they walk on every day and they can't even recognize it.
The protesters have formed a tribe. Their "product" is a true democracy where every individual voice is counted regardless of how much money the speaker has in the bank. No offense to the recently departed, but isn't that just a little more exciting than a skinny, white phone?
2. OWS protesters are lazy people looking for government handouts instead of jobs.
This is what Bill O'Reilly told my father (and millions of other viewers) on October 3, 2011.
I didn't take it very well.
I am 28 years old. I am healthy. I am intelligent. I want to work. I want to create. I want to contribute. I want to care for my family. I take pride in a job well done.
There will be freeloaders in any crowd, but I truly believe that the majority of my peers - whether they take part in the protests or not - want to work. They went to college. They harbor dreams of harnessing their passion to make a daily difference in the world. They want to work; as doctors, teachers, lawyers, entrepreneurs, fire fighters, programmers, scientists, artists, musicians, politicians. They want to earn. They want to give back. They believe in the American Dream as it was originally intended to be lived.
But this has become next to impossible. The jobs have disappeared as smaller companies have been forced out of business by giant corporations that turned around and sent their own job offerings overseas. The ones that remain offer such low wages that we cannot pay for the college degrees we earned to get those jobs.
Entrepreneurship is not for everyone. Business acumen is a talent just like painting or writing. Not everyone possesses it. Jobs are still a necessity for the people of this nation to survive.
We want them. Where are they?
3. OWS protesters cannot be taken seriously because they look like hippies.
This is probably the most common complaint lodged against OWS.
No, really.
When a journalist or random Twitter troll can't think of any intelligent reasons why OWS should go away, they resort to judging their style. Or their smell.
I can neither confirm nor deny the odor attributed to the protesters who have been camping out for almost three weeks now. But I deny the assertion that citizens must conform to the dress code of the status quo if they want to be treated with respect.
Last week, someone claiming sympathy with the protesters suggested that they should all show up in Polos and Khakis. The logic goes that if you want to represent The Everyman, you need to look like The Everyman.
The trouble with this logic is that the protesters already do.
Have you been to New York City? San Francisco? Portland? Austin? Any college campus in America? Nobody under the age of 30 is wearing Polos and Khakis unless they work for Best Buy or Chile's.
Holy jeans. T-shirts. Hoodies. This is our uniform. You be you. We'll be us.
I agree that some people might be going out of their way to live out their fantasy of the summer of '69, but at least they aren't wearing powdered wigs.
4. OWS is too monochromatic to represent the truly oppressed people of the U.S.
There are too many white people down there! Everyone knows white people can't feel pain!
Listen, this is 2011. Yes, racism exists. Yes, it's terrible. But these arguments only deepen racial divides by implying that white people have no right to voice their dissent against injustice unless non-white people show up to certify that injustice.
This thinking places non-white people in the perpetual role of the oppressed and bars white people entry to the Disenfranchised Club despite legitimate economic hardship caused by corporate greed. I just don't see how that helps any of us face the crisis at hand.
Red and yellow, black and white, we were ripped off in plain sight. Wall Street hates the little children of the world...
Furthermore, the accusations are becoming unfounded. Go to Flickr and search for Occupy Wall Street. Flip through the crowd photos. You'll see all kinds of faces. There was less diversity in the early days, but that has been steadily changing, especially after the solidarity march yesterday with many of the local Unions.
Still not enough to suit you? There's a simple solution: Tell all your non-white friends to get down there!
Blaming the people who have shown up for the people who haven't shown up yet is simply unfair. Commend the people who are doing the work no matter what color their skin is. Encourage more people to join in the work no matter what color their skin is. This is not a game. We don't have time for distractions. Just get down there and get to work.
5. OWS protesters have no right to complain; they're Americans!
This is similar to the racial argument, but on a global scale. It is just as unhelpful.
There are those who wish to remain in their fantasy land where poverty has not yet come to the United States. This is simply untrue. It is here now. It has been here forever. It will remain here if we do not take immediate, decisive measures to put an end to it and create a nation where every person who can and wants to work is able to support their family and where every person who is unable to work through no fault of their own has their basic needs met.
This argument seems to suggest that there is a Cosmic Queue where the downtrodden people of Earth must form a line based on the scale of the injustices they have suffered. Poor starving children of Africa must come first! Unemployed twenty-somethings of America must quietly wait their turn until these bigger problems have been solved.
Really? Who will send aid to other countries if we require it at home? How will we feed the children of Africa if we cannot feed the children of Arkansas?
The protesters of OWS are taking Ghandi's advice to heart. They are ready to be the change they wish to see in the world. Supporting them is supporting oppressed people all over the world because these are the kids who are going to inherit the Earth one way or another. These are the kids who will hold office one day. These are the kids who will make decisions of global importance one day. There is nothing anyone can do to change this fact unless they figure out how to stop time.
I did not ask to be born in the United States. That was beyond my control. I am here. I have rights that people born in other countries do not possess. So I have a responsibility to exercise those rights not just on behalf of myself, but on behalf of the people I share this country with, and on behalf of the people I share this planet with.
But the battle begins at home. We cannot help others if we cannot help ourselves. If we succeed in our quest to end corporate tyranny on our own turf, we will be in a much better position to put an end to other types of tyranny all over the world.
6. OWS protesters are hypocritical for using or consuming any brand name products.
Hold up.
First, we're accused of being unorganized.
Then, we're accused of being hypocrites for using organizational tools like laptops and smart phones.
Here's the deal. I don't think anybody wants Dunkin' Donuts to go out of business. They make damn good donuts. I don't think anybody wants Apple to go out of business. They make damn good computers.
The majority of protesters do not wish for corporations to cease to exist entirely. Rather, we want corporations to be held accountable for what they do with their profits.
We don't want corporations to donate money to political campaigns to effectively bribe candidates into making decisions based on the needs of the corporations rather than the people. We don't want corporations to hire lobbyists to sway Congress in their favor. We don't want corporations to accept bailout money from the government and then put millions of dollars into Christmas packages for their top execs. We don't want corporations to send their jobs overseas while people are starving in America. We don't want corporations to get away with paying no taxes.
Essentially, we do not want corporations to be treated with the same legal status as living, breathing, individual human beings... with more legal status than some living, breathing, individual human beings.
We want to buy their products. But we will not be their slaves. They work for us. They create things for us. They exist for us. They must play by our rules.
No more sweatshops. No more animal torture. No more pollution. No more sexual or racial discrimination. No more million dollar bonuses. No more billion dollar bailouts. No more tax breaks. No more corporate personhood.
7. OWS protesters admire Obama and ignore the role he played in our financial meltdown.
It's probably true that a majority of OWS protesters voted for Barack Obama if they were of age during the 2008 election. It's also true that many of them supported other candidates from across the political spectrum.
And it's probably true that many of them will vote for Obama again for lack of a better option. Many of these people are committed to civil rights causes that conservatives are staunchly against. (Though it appears there are a number of Ron Paul supporters in our midst.)
But we are not blind. We are not ignorant. We understand exactly what happened between the White House and Wall Street. And we are not happy about it.
We feel used. We believed the result of the 2008 election was historic beyond its racial implications. We believed we were voting for someone who was going to end the wars. We believed we were voting for someone who was going to champion human rights.
We took the bait hook, line, and sinker. And we got fried.
None of us expect Obama to ride in on a white horse and save us from the greedy corporate villains who have us tied to the railroad tracks.
We know by now that he has no intention of ever biting the hands that feed him.
We are disillusioned. Not delusional.
We will not place our dreams in sand castles ever again.
8. OWS is anti-American.
Wtf? Seriously?
Read the Constitution.
9. OWS protesters are all Communists who seek to destroy Capitalism and create a totalitarian state.
Say what?
I will affirm the supposition that many - but by no means all - protesters lean hard left. There are many who might identify as socialists. (Myself somewhat included.)
But we are not ignorant children. We know the horrors that have taken place in Communist regimes. We have studied the Soviet Union, North Vietnam, China, and the rest. That is not the future we have in mind.
You see, because we are not ignorant, we understand that there is more than one way to skin a cat and more than two ways to run a country. We do not have to have a two-party political system, and we do not have to have an either/or economic system.
There is a middle ground where the members of a society can enjoy personal freedom and a level economic playing field. It is possible to take the best elements from two systems and create one system that works for everyone.
This middle-ground will never be found while we cling to the dualism of the past. We must cease to label ourselves as Republicans or Democrats, as Socialists of Capitalists, and acknowledge that at the end of the day we are all just people. Nobody's hunger should ever be unsated. Nobody's creativity should ever be restrained. These are not mutually exclusive ideals.
If the corporations would simply choose to regulate the money they earn wisely and with respect for the needs of the people who build and buy their products... then what need would there be for government intervention?
If it comes to the point that the government must force the corporations to manage their money for the benefit of the people they serve, then the corporations will have no one to blame but themselves because they were given plenty of time to voluntarily mend their ways. There is still time.
This planet can provide abundantly for us all as long as nobody takes more than they need. It is not hard to achieve this aim voluntarily. It is not hard to take our faith out of systems and restore it to the people.
It is possible to create the American Dream we were promised. It is possible to create a society where we voluntarily work for the common good because we come to the mutual understanding that we are all connected and what happens to one happens to us all, and it is possible to bring that world into existence without force or government intervention. All it takes is for the people united to choose a new path together.
The One Truth
People keep demanding that we give them one demand.
They seem unaware that there is more than one problem, and thus more than one demand. Again we see how the world has been stripped of nuance...
But the truth is we do have One Demand.
We know exactly what it is.
If we are keeping it to ourselves it is only because we know the world is not ready to hear it yet.
It is so revolutionary that if it is ever put into practice, then everything will change.
Yes, that's how powerful our One Demand is. Everything would change.
The world is not yet ready for it. If we reveal it now, we will be ridiculed even more than we already are. We will be immediately written off as hopeless dreamers. No one will pay attention anymore.
But there is more at stake than our pride here. You see, everyone else throughout history who has made this One Demand has been killed. Assassinated.
Our only defense lies in our numbers. We must grow. We must spread to every city in every country around the world. We must make ourselves visible as the overwhelming majority so that those in power who wish to silence our message will know that it can never be done. If you strike one down, a thousand more will take his place.
This is what the people demanding to know our One Demand do not understand yet. It is not as simple as telling you what we want, accepting a sketchy promise to receive it, and going away. If only it were! If only it were something that could be passed into law, ratified into the Constitution of our land and every other land around the world!
But it cannot. It cannot be forced. It can only be chosen.
This is why we have not spelled it out.
We occupy to let them know we exist. We occupy to let them know we are angry. We occupy to let them know that we aren't going to take it anymore. We occupy so that they might see us every day, so that they might look into the crowd and make eye contact with another human being who deserves to live with dignity, so that having recognized that inherent dignity in their fellow man they might choose to place his needs equal to their own and choose to love modestly so that others do not go hungry while some grow fat.
We occupy so that we might share our stories with one another and with the world because our One Demand is not just directed at the super-rich but at every person who occupies this Earth. And not only that, but we must abide by our One Demand when face-to-face with those who have oppressed us because there is suffering in the human heart that no amount of money can ever assuage.
Read our stories. But more importantly, look into our eyes. Look into our human eyes made of the exact same material as your own. Do you see the despair? The fear? The exhaustion? The betrayal?
And do you see the timid hope in those eyes? That maybe this might be the start of something new?
Do you see the One Demand now? It is right there in those eyes. It is right there in the eyes of the protesters on the street. You will find it in the eyes of the old woman in the park. You will find it in the eyes of the man looking for work. You will find it in the eyes of the pregnant woman on the train. It's all around you.
You'll know it if you take the time to truly look.
Actually...
Fuck that. We're running out of time.
I'm just going to tell you what it is.
Two Words.
One Demand.
Have Mercy.
That's all.
It never had to be this hard.
Let's start now.
"I have always found that mercy bears richer fruits than strict justice." ~ Abraham Lincoln.
Written by Chase Night. Originally published at Unbridled Existence on October 7, 2011.